Modern life will kill us

Now that there are no elections grabbing my attention I’ve begun casting the net a bit wider as I look for things to read about. Recently two things have caught my attention, one is an interesting tirade from a US banking executive, he predicts that US credit card defaults will lead to another wave of financial instability. And the other was Clusterfuck Nation, the blog of Jim Kunstler, which I found in lemmiwinks’ sidebar. More than ever, I think that we are at the beginning of a massive shift in not just our global economy, but our very way of life.

The first article reinforced my suspicion that we are a long way from seeing the end of this economic downturn, the seeds have been sown for a catastrophic meltdown and harvest time has come. It seems amazing that in February economists were talking about how the worst of the ‘credit crunch’ was over, only for the CDO mess to eliminate billions of dollars of wealth, based on a sub-prime mortgage market that in hindsight was destined to fail.

The US government has looked for ways to prop up the financial industry, with the $700 Billion treasury cash injection grabbing most of the headlines, despite only representing a part of what has actually been spent. At the same time, Detroit’s car manufacturers are being dragged over the coals in order to have their request for assistance heard. It reeks of class warfare, merchant bankers who have effectively been doing nothing more than gambling with other people’s money are bailed out unconditionally, while millions of blue collar jobs are on the line as the CEOs of these, admittedly poorly run, companies are made to grovel.

We have been finding artificial means of enabling consumption, most recently through robbing the equity in our homes, while simultaneously reducing the wages and conditions of most people. It couldn’t last. Now that house prices have tumbled in the US and the UK people are scrambling to find ways to not only overcome the negative equity in their homes, but also to maintain all of the other expenses that they felt safe racking up during the housing bubble.

I remember the first few large ticket items that I bought on credit were from Harvey Norman, you needed 1/3rd deposit and paid a fixed rate of interest. Now they always push you to the GE supplied “pay nothing/ owe heaps” finance instead, which is much more likely to to cause financial difficulty to people. One of the worst elements of these credit providers is that during the interest free period of your loan they have as little interaction with you as possible, no monthly reminders to pay back your debt, they leave that until you are paying 23% interest along with monthly account keeping fees. Easy credit has been a necessity to continue consumption, a misguided attempt to maintain middle class lifestyles while people’s ability to afford those lifestyles was being undermined by the broader economy.

I think that our addiction to consumption and using expansion and growth as the only measures of a healthy economy are about to change dramatically.

This leads me to James Kunstler. I’m presently reading his book The Long Emergency in which he lays out his predictions for how our world will change post peak oil. A large part of his thesis revolves around the idea that there is no substitute available for oil, we are about to see a decline in its availability, but that our modern society is entirely constructed around the idea that oil is cheap and plentiful.

On Kunstler’s hit list are suburbs, commercial agriculture, global trade, and highways along with a few other sacred cows of the modern world. He argues that none of these things are sustainable once we start seeing oil scarcity and demonstrates, by referencing the oil shocks of the 70’s, how even a small reduction in oil availability can lead to enormous impacts on the economy and our way of life.

The volatility of oil prices over the past two years seems to fit the pattern predicted for peak oil, and we are certainly in the midst of the decade when it has been forecast. Are we ready to deal with a world where oil is rationed and expensive? Sadly I think we’re a long way from it. When something as obvious as climate change is being rejected by so many people, how on earth will they react to the idea that the oil age, and all of the 20th century advances that were made with it, are over and our way of life must change?

I don’t think that we’re headed for a Mad Max style post apocalyptic wasteland, but I do think that the era of commuting to the CBD of a major city from housing estates on the fringes will soon be a thing of the past. The question becomes, what else will be willing, or forced to give up as part of our new reality?

7 thoughts on “Modern life will kill us

  1. I have little sympathy for the car manufacturers both here and overseas. They kept/keep flogging gigantic inefficient behemoths regardless. I think this is attempting to dictate to the market, but it doesn’t work that way.

    As for JHK, I don’t agree with much of his vision of the future, though we’re in agreement about trains. I don’t think it will be anywhere near as bad as he predicts, but who can tell for sure?

    If you haven’t seen them, you may enjoy “The End of Suburbia” and “PBS Affluenza”. The latter is scattered about youtube in 6 parts, but I’ve got it and will gladly supply you both on a disc if you like.

  2. Perhaps the future may hold one of the following to be true: Suburbia will survive due the extensive rail network that shall be built, linking suburbs to the cities with high speed trains.

    Or perhaps we will see the emergence, supported by the internet, of Westfield style developments in the suburbs that house, rather than retails stores, offices. These offices will be rented by city corporations that allow their staff member to stay in their community but still maintain an office away from their home (where there is limited productivity). The costs will be offset by having hundreds of businesses under the one roof, all contributing to the outgoings; the reduced requirement for larger city premises; and ease of face to face contact with clients. The size of the store/office will be determined by the company’s needs and prestige. Large admin centres could also defer costs. This concept, with plenty of parking and open spaces, will give the employee the sense of being part of a community without the need to commute to the city or work in an office tower. It will also stop the need for businesses to grow to a large size before contemplating decentralization. And like Westfield, the staffing of the premises, food retailers, banks, dry cleaners post offices and cleaners, will all be locally employed. With numerous, large childcare centres attached, this might be the key to reigniting the nuclear family and allow for work mums.

    Also, by keeping the thousands of employees in their communities, surely that will improve the economies of the suburbs? Maybe not the end of suburbia but rather the shot in the arm that they need!

  3. Well I don’t think that peak oil is fiction, I think it’s going to be very disruptive to our way of life.

    As far as the world going on the same as it did before, do you mean before we had cheap and plentiful oil? Because that’s going to be quite different to what we have now. I don’t think we’re facing armageddon, in fact I think that Australia will fare better than a lot of other first world nations, but I do wonder how the changes will affect us.

    Lee, I’d like to believe that mass transit would solve many of the problems that suburbia has created, but I suspect that you’ll struggle to find may governments who have a rail budget larger than their road budget.

    As to the idea of distributed work environments, I think that they’d be a good start, but the transition to these things will be difficult because by the time we realise we need to change so dramatically, we will already be facing resource shortages.

    That’s the crux of the problem really, most of the problems that come with peak oil can only be seen in hindsight.

  4. Agreed Dave, peak oil is a simple fact – there’s only a finite amount of it in the ground. The only real question is when, not if. I’m not entirely convinced we’re there yet. The USA went to great lengths to sucker a few of it’s mates into kicking the shit out of Iraq to get control of that oil, and there are some real unknowns in Kurdistan where the oil is seeping out of the ground and it’s yet to be extracted. Whether there’s enough there to make a significant impact or not is an entirely different question.

    Regardless, I think the real question is is there any reason not to change? Ignoring for a moment the cost, is there any other reason why every suitable surface on the roof of every single building shouldn’t be covered in solar panels to produce electricity?

  5. I just think mankind will adapt to changing circumstances, Dave, as we have done throughout all history. Sure there’ll be changes but if you stand back and look at the evolution of the world the changes that have occurred have improved life for the better. I’ve every confidence that the oil situation will be overcome and we are better off focusing on things we as individuals CAN control rather than worrying about things we can’t.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s