This morning on Radio National Breakfast, Fran Kelly interviewed Robert Brown from the NSW Shooters’ Party about a private member’s bill that he plans to introduce into the upper house of the NSW Parliament.  The crux of the bill is that it removes some of the discrepancies in NSW law relating to hunters performing pest control, it would extend to National Parks the same system that presently exists, quite successfully, in State Forests and give farmers more choice about how they managed kangaroo culls on their own properties. What sounded like a fairly straight forward piece of legislation, that can only be successful with the support of the government, really seemed to raise Fran’s ire.

From the start of the interview Fran sounded hostile, a fact not lost on her guest, who sounded increasingly frustrated with her seeming indifference to his answers. Every question asked was answered in a straight forward manner, without obfuscation, in fact it was a great pleasure to hear an elected representative being so open about a policy position. Despite that, Fran seemed entirely unwilling to concede that any good may come of allowing hunters to destroy pests in National Parks, she refused to accept that killing feral animals was a genuine conservation initiative and then bizarrely dismissed the entire idea because the hunters hadn’t killed enough feral animals to make a difference in the areas that they were allowed access to.

Hunters aren’t a group that elicit a lot of sympathy in the general community, most people’s ideas are probably formed by what they see on the cover of magazines like Bacon Busters or Wild Boar Australia at their newsagents, but the reality is that, like any group, hunters are a diverse group with a variety of interests. Popular culture might paint hunters as backwards rednecks, but  I would have expected Fran Kelley to be a little more open minded and professional.

I wonder how much of Fran’s attitude towards hunters comes from ignorance? Even in rural areas hunting is not a high profile activity, so I can only imagine that for people living and working in metropolitan centres the very idea of hunting would be something quite foreign. The reality is that the majority of people who hunt for sport are quite committed to it, spend a lot of time and money equipping themselves to do it properly and take great care when using firearms. Those who hunt on a commercial basis approach the sport with an enormous amount of professionalism and operate within a well regulated system.

Whether this bill goes anywhere will depend entirely upon the NSW government, but I hope that if they do decide to seriously look at it that the level of discourse is a little better than what was delivered on Radio National this morning.

Take a listen for yourself  

4 thoughts on “Preconceptions

  1. Sounds to me like the interviewer was aiming this squarely metro dwellers and not interested in taking a more bi-partisan approach.

    Hunters in general get bad press and it’s my opinion that it’s more than likely a minority that spoils it for the majority.

  2. I normally love the ABC for it’s leanings to teh left but this is a typical example of the closed minded attitude which I despise. Guns are bad, ergo anyone who owns or *gasp* uses one is very, very bad indeed and you should probably be afraid of them because they’re obviously some kind of weirdo. I’ve gotten used to changing the channel/turning the radio off in such situations, no point getting bent out of shape over it.

    Having said that, the Shooters Party is firmly on my shit list because they (along with resident nut job Fred Nile) refused to support a bill which would have protected the fertile farming land on the Liverpool Plains from mining exploration because it was a “greenie” bill. Cunts!

  3. I agree that the Shooter’s Party are, for the most part, a reactionary pain in the butt. I think it’s problematic when we become so closed minded that we can’t look at an issue on its merits, and dangerous when journalists do so.

  4. i heard the interview and noted Fran did not want to hear any argument for licenced shooters to kill feral animals in national parks. Pigs especially could carry
    disease and do destroy crops beyond the boundaries.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s